posted on February 27th 2017 in Austin CFP Team Posts with 0 Comments /

This post is a preview of WorthPointe’s e-book Evidence-Based Investing: Separating Fact From Fiction, written by Certified Financial Planner™ Scott O’Brien. In Evidence-Based Investing, Scott discusses the myths and misinformation that most often slow or halt our financial goals. Get your complimentary copy of Evidence-Based Investing here.

Just because a certain money manager or mutual fund beats the market for a few years, you shouldn’t jump to the conclusion that it was due to being smarter or more skilled. Most likely, it was dumb luck.

The odds of beating a benchmark in any one year are 50%. Then the odds of beating the benchmark three years in a row is the same as flipping a coin and getting heads three times in a row — an occurrence that is expected 12% of the time.

So with thousands of fund managers in the investment field, shouldn’t we expect 12% of them to beat their benchmark for three years in a row simply by random chance? Since this is statistically likely, why would you place any predictive value on the likelihood that the managers in the top 12% will continue to outperform? You shouldn’t.

Mark Carhart did a study that tracked fund performances back to 1962. He concluded that performers in the top 10 percent in any one year are more likely to fall to the bottom 10 percent than to repeat in the top 10 percent.

CNBC often trots out the latest manager who has beaten the market averages, anoints them as the latest flavor of the month and implies they are someone we should listen to for investment advice for the next 10 minutes.

Since there is no evidence of persistency of performance in fund returns beyond what could be randomly expected, a logical person must not attribute a particular fund’s outperformance to skill instead of luck.
Read the rest in Evidence-Based Investing. Get Your Complete Copy of the Book Now.

about the author: Scott W. O'Brien CFP®, EA

scottScott W. O’Brien CFP® is a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER professional who serves clients by coordinating their financial lives and assisting them in making smart financial decisions within the areas of investments, retirement planning, insurance strategies, tax minimization, and estate planning.

Scott was honored as the winner of the 2015 Five Star Professional Wealth Manager for Austin, San Antonio and the Central Texas region. He has been quoted in the Wall Street Journal, US News & World Report, MainStreet.com and Investopedia.

Learn more and/or Contact Scott

Continue Reading

Other articles filed under Austin CFP Team Posts

How Do We Compare to Austin’s Best Financial Planning Firms?

February 28, 2019 - Every year, the Austin Business Journal publishes its annual Book of Lists. This downloadable document or print book — both available for purchase — lists the “hottest area companies in their field” based on ranking criteria specified by field. In...
Continue Reading

2018 Year-End Investment Market Report

January 30, 2019 - This was the year the long, seemingly endless bull market came to a crashing halt — and U.S. investors finally, for the first time since 2008, experienced the normal definition of a bear market (down 20% from the S&P 500's...
Continue Reading

Picking Funds Based on Performance: A Fool’s Game

January 23, 2019 - You’ve probably heard from the do-it-yourselfer at your office. “I just invest in the funds with the best performance.” But is this a reasonable? Though a book could be written citing numerous academic studies to address the validity of this...
Continue Reading

What Attracted our Advisors to WorthPointe?

January 22, 2019 - Each of our advisors was drawn to something slightly different at WorthPointe. We take great satisfaction in giving our partners the career they dream of. Here are a few of their stories. Meet Morgan Advisor by day and surfer by...
Continue Reading

Here for You, Anywhere You Are

January 8, 2019 - Here at WorthPointe, we want to help you get the most out of life. We are constantly rethinking the traditional features of a wealth management firm and reworking them to better fit your busy lifestyle. This includes our online presence...
Continue Reading

Return to Blog Home