There is something about October that spooks investors. Maybe it’s the market crash of 1929 or the one-day crash that happened in 1987. More recently, shares were pummeled in October 2008 after Lehman’s collapse roiled global credit markets.
Though it has been a while, modest corrections in the late 1970s ruffled feathers in October. Almost 20 years ago, the mini-crash of 1997 that was tied to the economic crisis in Asia played out shortly before Halloween.
However, October’s scary reputation belies reality. Since 1970, the S&P 500 Index has averaged a monthly advance of 0.99% in October. So much for its spooky reputation.
Over the last 45 years, September has registered an average drop of 0.72%, far below August, which is second from the bottom, or an average return of 0.0%. For reasons that aren’t fully understood, September has historically been a tough month for investors. And you can’t just pin its lousy performance on a few bad years.
Some explanations seem plausible, though they can’t be conclusively proven.
According to Investopedia, one theory suggests that summer is usually marked by lighter volume, as investors typically go on vacation and refrain from selling stocks. When they return, they exit shares they had planned to sell.
Another camp puts the blame on mutual funds. You see, many mutual funds set their fiscal year end in September. Therefore, fund managers, on average, may decide to sell losing positions before the end of the fiscal year, which leads to September’s subpar performance.
That theory may hold some water. When the index (in this case, the Dow) has been up for the year — as it is now — it usually means the month finishes up, though returns are “still not great,” according to Bespoke Investment Group.
Whatever the cause, if the reasons could be pinpointed, selling would likely commence in August, as short-term traders would be hoping to sidestep September. That would eliminate the distortions caused by September sales activity.
In any case, here’s the next question that typically comes to mind: “Should I sell in September and re-enter when the long-term averages suggest we’ll be in a more favorable climate for stocks?”
We would caution you (and we probably have) to be careful with averages, as they are just that — averages.
We may consider paring back positions this month, or in any month, but it would have nothing to do with September’s historical weakness and everything to do with your personal circumstances.
We are reminded of a comment made by the legendary Warren Buffett, who once quipped, “The only value of stock forecasters is to make fortune-tellers look good.”
Or something said by Peter Lynch, who successfully ran Fidelity’s Magellan Fund during a long period of explosive returns, who noted, “Far more money has been lost by investors preparing for corrections, or trying to anticipate corrections, than has been lost in corrections themselves.”
Turn the page and close the chapter on a dull August
How boring is boring, asks LPL Research Group? We may be near a record high, but using closing prices, the S&P 500 traded in a 1.54% range in August — the smallest monthly range since August 1995.
In fact, only six months have had a narrower monthly span, going all the way back to 1928!
Table 1: Key Index Returns
|MTD %||YTD %||3-year* %|
|Dow Jones Industrial Average||-0.2||+5.6||+7.5|
|S&P 500 Index||-0.1||+6.2||+10.0|
|Russell 2000 Index||+1.6||+9.2||+7.0|
|MSCI World ex-USA**||-0.2||-0.4||-0.4|
|MSCI Emerging Markets**||+2.3||+12.5||-1.3|
Source: Wall Street Journal, MSCI.com, MTD returns: July 29, 2016 – August 31, 2016
YTD returns: December 31, 2015 – August 31, 2016, *Annualized, **in U.S. dollars
A review of the returns for the major averages tells a similar story. The NASDAQ Composite posted a modest gain in August, while the Dow and the S&P 500 inched lower. The term “dog days of summer” could not have been more suitable this year.
But August is behind us and we are in the so-called “dreaded” month of September. What’s in store and what might create a bumpier road, at least in the short term, for investors?
While we won’t venture a guess as to where we’ll end the month, let me spend a moment reviewing possible events that could awaken the market from its sleepy August.
We’ve been hearing chatter the Federal Reserve might hike interest rates as soon as September.
“I believe the case for an increase in the fed funds rate has strengthened in recent months,” said Fed Chief Janet Yellen near the end of August. By itself, the statement really isn’t earthshattering, but it is a signal she’s eyeing a rate hike later this year.
But in an interview on CNBC later in the day, her number two at the Fed, Vice Chair Stanley Fischer, surprised investors by saying that her remarks were “consistent” with two rate increases this year. Of course, he was quick to add that it all depends on the economic data.
Nonetheless, an increase at the September 21 meeting could create short-term volatility in shares, even though rates would remain near historically low levels.
While it seems unlikely the dovish Fed would insert itself into the election by rocking the boat, that possibility certainly exists.
If not rates, then what? Record highs signal investors aren’t fretting over the upcoming election. With the exception of the political junkies, voters historically don’t really get engaged until after Labor Day.
Yet, a tightening in the race could create additional uncertainty as we head toward November.
Then there is the ever-present possibility that international woes could wash up on our shores. Recently, we had a front row seat to the emotional responses wrought by China and Brexit.
Once investors realized overseas worries weren’t mucking up the shores of the U.S. economy, cooler heads prevailed.
These are just some of our more recent concerns. We won’t belabor the point by lifting up every rock that might provide a September surprise, but now is a good reminder during the market’s recent calm that volatility can strike. When it does (note, we say “when” not “if”), your financial plan is designed to reduce overall risk while keeping the focus on the long term.
Economy – the good news
We never want to end on a gloomy note. Even during the depths of the Great Recession, we could look up to see the glimmer of distant lights.
A quick review of the economic data reveals an economy that has recently gained a bit of momentum. It’s not the fast-paced growth we experienced during the 1980s or the “brimming with confidence” economy of the late 1990s. But the improvements are cautiously encouraging.
Though business spending remains weak, employment growth has accelerated (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics), weekly first-time jobless claims are holding at historically low levels (Dept. of Labor) and consumer spending has come out of its winter hibernation (U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis).
While we are the first to counsel against taking on needless debt for what are needless purchases, consumer spending accounts for 70% of GDP. Therefore, more engaged consumers help lift the economy.
Why does this matter? As we’ve pointed out before, the biggest long-term driver of stock prices is corporate profits, and a growing economy creates a tailwind for them.
You’ve heard us say this before: stick to the plan. From a behavioral standpoint, it’s usually easier to adhere to your financial plan when markets are moving higher.
If your circumstances have changed, we should talk, as adjustments may be in order.
In any case, you must be comfortable with the level of risk in your portfolio. If you are not, let’s talk and recalibrate.
Other articles filed under Market Commentary
July 5, 2017 - A Book Review: “Those who remain covet any living creature, and for people who can’t afford one, companies built incredibly realistic simulacra: horses, birds, cats, sheep. They’ve even built robot (“robo”) financial advisors. Immigrants to Mars receive robo advisors so...
June 22, 2017 - The steady diet of headlines pouring out of the Trump administration has been unsettling for most Americans, regardless of where they sit on the political spectrum. We know equity markets loathe heightened uncertainty — and what is happening in Washington...
May 24, 2017 - Stocks at home and overseas have experienced a run up in prices over the last six months. After the S&P 500 Index claimed a new high on March 1, it has more or less held within a narrow range. That hasn’t...
May 21, 2017 - Successfully managing a financial windfall We’ve all heard the stories, if not firsthand, at least in various news reports and anecdotes. Some “lucky” person picks the winning numbers; prances before the cameras in what can only be described as a media...
April 22, 2017 - There was no shortage of angst in the investment community that a Donald Trump victory in last year’s election would send shares down sharply, at least in the immediate aftermath of a Trump win. In reality, just the opposite happened,...
- What You Need to Know About Credit
- Insurance for Women in Transition